Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
Show all changes
39 commits
Select commit Hold shift + click to select a range
f3d7b53
docs(crosscheck): define evidence-led website scope and acceptance
Oct 28, 2026
15a2100
feat(crosscheck): lead website with pinned EVerest evidence study
Oct 28, 2026
35bc3ee
docs(crosscheck): clarify the worktree preview URL
Oct 28, 2026
02bb00a
docs(crosscheck): define career evidence and home-server launch scope
Oct 28, 2026
28f980f
feat(crosscheck): explain study contributions and prepare home-server…
Oct 28, 2026
5189927
docs(crosscheck): brief the EVerest-only case-study site
hnipps Oct 28, 2026
d68a6bb
feat(crosscheck): make the EVerest case study the whole site
hnipps Oct 28, 2026
842a451
fix(crosscheck): keep each short answer as qualified as its source
hnipps Oct 28, 2026
92d68cc
fix(crosscheck): break replay commands only at slashes and spaces
hnipps Oct 28, 2026
032f725
docs(crosscheck): record the case-study page in DESIGN.md
hnipps Oct 28, 2026
d21c3fb
feat(crosscheck): arrange the study like balfrontower.org
hnipps Oct 28, 2026
808cf30
feat(crosscheck): explain EVerest and OCPP and keep the filters in view
hnipps Oct 28, 2026
61ae08c
docs(crosscheck): add five Crosscheck logo options drafted with Codex…
hnipps Oct 28, 2026
47738c3
docs(crosscheck): take Codex's final pass on the logo options
hnipps Oct 28, 2026
b424fcf
feat(crosscheck): open the About section with what EVerest and OCPP are
hnipps Oct 28, 2026
8974206
feat(crosscheck): centre the study in a narrower column, like balfron…
hnipps Oct 28, 2026
3d5b4dd
docs(crosscheck): add five round-two Crosscheck logo options from Codex
hnipps Oct 28, 2026
44cc8a2
feat(crosscheck): move the EVerest and OCPP detail into the glossary
hnipps Oct 28, 2026
3c60950
feat(crosscheck): adopt the Counterproof mark for Crosscheck
hnipps Oct 28, 2026
c24dc8d
fix(crosscheck): set the Crosscheck wordmark at the mark's size, in t…
hnipps Oct 28, 2026
405c9dd
fix(crosscheck): centre the wordmark's capitals on the mark
hnipps Oct 28, 2026
b699e3e
fix(crosscheck): make the study title the page's clear primary heading
hnipps Oct 28, 2026
829527e
refactor(crosscheck): remove stylesheet rules for components the site…
hnipps Oct 29, 2026
86cbb54
docs(crosscheck): describe the shipped study page in DESIGN.md
hnipps Oct 29, 2026
52b9a93
fix(crosscheck): land shared question links on the answer
hnipps Oct 29, 2026
4dde1f6
feat(crosscheck): open the evidence for a chosen question and size th…
hnipps Oct 29, 2026
570eba8
fix(crosscheck): clarify the finding line, the insider IDs and the gl…
hnipps Oct 29, 2026
f65dfb3
feat(crosscheck): group the questions, quiet the strengths and name e…
hnipps Oct 29, 2026
bde1026
fix(crosscheck): polish the study page and make it easier to use on a…
hnipps Oct 29, 2026
4c6c8e9
fix(crosscheck): keep the full conformance rule in the Q4 gloss
hnipps Oct 29, 2026
19c553e
fix(crosscheck): keep each section's first line on one line, open or …
hnipps Oct 29, 2026
aa21fe0
feat(crosscheck): link the OCPP 1.6 specification and move People last
hnipps Oct 29, 2026
6c002e8
fix(crosscheck): hang the section labels so each section reads from o…
hnipps Oct 29, 2026
7cc5032
fix(crosscheck): set the Crosscheck wordmark at 28px
hnipps Oct 29, 2026
7bcf2e6
fix(crosscheck): set the footer as a colophon on the filter row's grid
hnipps Oct 29, 2026
4c4dccf
feat(crosscheck): make the study page plain, shareable and readable w…
hnipps Oct 30, 2026
e3c5b4f
fix(crosscheck): let weight, not size, separate the wordmark from the…
hnipps Oct 30, 2026
ee50c93
feat(crosscheck): make the study site findable, shareable and readabl…
hnipps Oct 30, 2026
e82bb1a
feat(crosscheck): make the glossary read like the study and balance t…
hnipps Oct 30, 2026
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
461 changes: 461 additions & 0 deletions .impeccable/design.json

Large diffs are not rendered by default.

54 changes: 54 additions & 0 deletions .impeccable/logos-prompt-round2.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,54 @@
Use the $impeccable skill for this task. It is brand-mark work inside an established visual world: load the skill's guidance on new visual work and its craft floor, and follow its discipline (diverge widely before converging, refuse category defaults, verify the render). Do not run its interactive question flow: the brief below is the answer to those questions, from the project's maintainer.

# Task: five new Crosscheck logo marks (round 2)

Write files only inside `.impeccable/logos/`. Do not edit anything else.

## What the mark must say

Read `docs/VISION.md` and `PRODUCT.md` before sketching. Crosscheck is a suite of tools for verifying AI-generated code. Its convictions, in the maintainer's words: **evidence, proof, transparency, not trusting LLMs, rigor.**

- No guarantee rests on an LLM's judgment. An LLM may draft code, specs and proofs, but only deterministic checks (Lean and Dafny proofs, differential tests, a contract-graph checker) and recorded human decisions count as evidence.
- Evidence comes in grades, and Crosscheck always says which: proved, tested, decided by a person, assumed, not yet reached. It never issues a blanket "approved".
- Every result shows its working: its assumptions, its trusted base, and where it stops. Nothing is hidden behind a verdict.
- "Crosscheck" means checking one account against an independent second one. In the first public study, a Lean model and EVerest's C++ code were run on the same inputs, and they disagreed by one second.

## What happened in round 1

Open `.impeccable/logos/index.html` and `NOTES.md` to see the first five marks. The maintainer's verdict: 4 and 5 are the closest, "but they're not great". Keep `mark-4.svg` exactly as it is. Delete nothing; marks 1, 2, 3 and 5 stay on disk but leave the comparison sheet.

Why round 1 fell short:
- Three of five marks were checkmarks. A tick means "approved", which is exactly the blanket verdict Crosscheck refuses to give. **No checkmarks or ticks in any form this round.**
- Mark 4, the divided QED square, works because it is a compact, solid silhouette with a real proof reference. Its weakness is that a diagonally split square is generic, and it says "proof" but not "independent check" or "transparency".
- Mark 5, the compared readings, says "comparison and disagreement", but it reads as a waveform or a circuit symbol, and it is spindly at 24px.

The bar: each new mark must be as solid and compact as 4, as specific to Crosscheck as 5 wanted to be, and distinctive enough that nobody could mistake it for another developer tool.

## Banned

Checkmarks and ticks; shields; padlocks and keys; magnifying glasses; eyes; brains, sparkles, stars or anything "AI"; circuit traces and waveforms; code brackets `</>` and `{}`; the letter C in a circle; gradients, outlines-of-filled-shapes as a style trick, and anything that only works in colour.

## Territories to mine (sources, not shapes; invent the form yourself)

- The notation of proof: the turnstile ⊢ ("proves") and double turnstile ⊨ ("models"), the end-of-proof square ∎, inference bars.
- Audit and record-keeping: a ledger rule, a witness's countersignature, a notary's perforation, a tally, a double-entry balance.
- Independent witnesses: two accounts that must agree, a second reading taken from a different instrument.
- Measurement and calibration: a plumb line, a set square, a reference mark, a tolerance.
- Showing the working: a form drawn open so its inside is visible, a boundary that is drawn rather than hidden, a trusted base marked explicitly.
- Refusal of blind trust: something that does not accept a claim until a second thing meets it.

## Method

1. Diverge: write at least 15 concepts, one line each, drawn from at least four different territories above (or better ones you find). Put them in `NOTES-round2.md`.
2. Score every concept 1 to 5 against each of the five convictions, and against distinctiveness and legibility at 24px. Keep the scores in the notes.
3. Build the best five that are also the most different from each other and from mark 4. No two may share a construction idea.
4. Craft each one: a self-contained SVG using paths and shapes only (no `<text>`, no fonts, no rasters), `fill`/`stroke` as `currentColor`, a tight `viewBox`, whole- or half-unit coordinates, one consistent stroke weight per mark or solid fills, and optical balance at 24px. A mark should be recognisable in silhouette, filled solid.
5. Verify: render each mark at 24px and 160px, for example with `magick` (ImageMagick is installed) or headless Chrome, and look at the result. Redraw any mark that blurs, fills in, or loses its idea at 24px. Record in the notes what you changed after looking.

## Deliverables

- `.impeccable/logos/mark-6.svg` to `mark-10.svg`.
- Update `.impeccable/logos/index.html` so it shows mark 4 and marks 6 to 10 only, each at 24px, 64px and 160px on paper `#f8f7f4`, in a lockup with the word "Crosscheck" set in a serif (Georgia is fine), once inverted (paper on ink `#18191b`), and once at 22px above the line "EVerest OCPP lib: a formal study" as it will sit on the site. Under each, add one sentence on the idea, one naming which of the five convictions it carries, and one on its risk.
- `.impeccable/logos/NOTES-round2.md`: the concept list with scores, the five chosen with reasons, what the 24px check changed, and your recommendation with the runner-up.

The world it lives in (unchanged): warm paper `#f8f7f4`, ink `#18191b`, rules `#7d808a`, a single highlighter yellow `#f8eab4` used sparingly, link blue `#2a5a9e`; Newsreader serif for reading, Public Sans for labels; flat and ruled, with hairline rules, no shadows and no gradients. The mark should look like it was set by a careful typographer for a research record, not drawn for an app store.
24 changes: 24 additions & 0 deletions .impeccable/logos-prompt.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,24 @@
Design five distinct logo alternatives for Crosscheck. Write files only inside `.impeccable/logos/`. Do not edit anything else in the repository.

## What Crosscheck is

Read `docs/VISION.md` and `PRODUCT.md` first. In short: Crosscheck is a suite of tools for verifying AI-generated code. Its rule is that no guarantee rests on an LLM's judgment. Only deterministic checks (Lean and Dafny proofs, differential tests, a contract-graph checker) and recorded human decisions count as evidence. It makes claims inspectable: each result states its strength (proved, tested, decided by a person, assumed, not yet reached), its assumptions and its limits. The name comes from checking one thing against an independent second thing. The first public use is a study in which a Lean model was compared with EVerest's charging-schedule code, finding a restart one second early.

## Where the logo lives

It sits at the top left of a reading site called "EVerest OCPP lib: a formal study", above that title, at roughly 20 to 28px tall. It also appears in the footer next to "The tool behind this study: Crosscheck". The site's visual world is called "The Evidence Record":
- warm paper ground `#f8f7f4`, ink `#18191b`, rules in `#7d808a` / `#b6b8be`
- one accent, highlighter yellow `#f8eab4`, used sparingly
- link blue `#2a5a9e`
- type: Newsreader (a text serif) for reading, Public Sans for labels, IBM Plex Mono for commands
- flat and ruled: hairline rules, no shadows, no gradients, square or barely rounded corners
The logo must belong in that world: quiet, precise, typographic, like a mark on a well-set research record. It must not look like a startup app icon.

## Deliverables

1. Five SVG marks: `.impeccable/logos/mark-1.svg` to `mark-5.svg`. Each is a self-contained SVG using paths and shapes only (no `<text>`, no external fonts, no raster images). Use `currentColor` for ink so the mark can recolour, and literal `#f8eab4` if a concept uses the highlighter. Use a tight `viewBox` and make it legible at 20px tall.
2. Each concept must come from a different idea. Do not make five variations of one shape. Candidate ideas to choose from or beat: two independent strokes that must agree; a check mark ruled against a reference line; a ledger tick; a proof's end mark (∎ / QED) recast; a crossing that forms a check; a diff or comparison of two readings. Avoid the obvious clichés (shield, padlock, magnifying glass, a generic tick in a circle, brackets around a tick).
3. `.impeccable/logos/index.html`: a comparison sheet showing each mark at 24px, 64px and 160px on the paper ground, in a lockup with the word "Crosscheck" set in a serif (Georgia fallback is fine), and once inverted (paper on ink). Under each, add one sentence on the idea and one on its risk. Inline the SVGs so the page renders from disk.
4. `.impeccable/logos/NOTES.md`: the five ideas, one paragraph each, and which one you recommend and why.

Keep the geometry clean: whole-pixel or half-pixel coordinates, consistent stroke weight within a mark, and optical balance at small sizes.
Loading
Loading