Indicator only controls one fan

[theangrydev]

On my P7xxDM2(-G) (according to dmidecode -t baseboard) there are two fans.

I am only able to control the one on the left.

Is there another hardware register than can be manipulated to control the other fan? How did you manage to find the address?

[theangrydev]

The embedded controller has some debug descriptors at /sys/kernel/debug/ec/*/{gpe,use_global_lock,io} that are documented here:
https://www.kernel.org/doc/Documentation/ABI/testing/debugfs-ec

There is a tool that can be used to read them here:
http://ftp.suse.com/pub/people/trenn/sources/ec/ec_access.c

[deebfeast]

This is how I have done it for Clevo NH55RDQ and its two fans. Just call function ec_write_fan_duty twice but use different values for the fan number.

Like:

ec_io_do(0x99, 0x01, v_i);
ec_io_do(0x99, 0x02, v_i);

Works like a charm.

For reading also twice, e.g. for Clevo NH55RDQ

#define EC_REG_FAN_1_DUTY 0xCE
#define EC_REG_FAN_2_DUTY 0xCF
#define EC_REG_FAN_1_RPMS_HI 0xD0
#define EC_REG_FAN_1_RPMS_LO 0xD1
#define EC_REG_FAN_2_RPMS_HI 0xD2
#define EC_REG_FAN_2_RPMS_LO 0xD3

// replace X with fan number of build a list or counter to loop
raw_duty = ec_io_read(EC_REG_FAN_X_DUTY);
raw_rpm_hi = ec_io_read(EC_REG_FAN_X_HI);
raw_rpm_lo = ec_io_read(EC_REF_FAN_X_LO);

[junocomp]

@deebfeast can you share your clevo-indicator.c if you still have it.

I tried your solution but I don't think I'm doing it right.

[deebfeast]

Of course. See attachment.

For me e.g. clevo-indicator 20 silences the laptop but sticks to that cycle of course.
Start the usual clevo-indicator -? for a dump of values.
Just starting the GUI does work but you might want to tune the AUTO options a bit further.
GPU readings are not working here so I left it out for now.

clevo-indicator.c.txt

[junocomp]

I included part of your code into my script but it still only controls 1 fan (left). Would you mind trying mine and see if you have the same result please.

clevo-indicator.c.txt

[deebfeast]

Here you seem to still fix the fan number on 0x01. Diff:

535c534
<     return ec_io_do(0x99, fan_number, v_i);
---
>     return ec_io_do(0x99, 0x01, v_i);

[junocomp]

@deebfeast I made the changes and it compiled just fine but is still controlling only one fan. I was thinking of maybe just running the indicator for the second fan alone and two clevo-indicators for each fan but I can't seem to figure out how to do that either.

[deebfeast]

Do you have the same model, Clevo NH55RDQ? Perhaps things have changed. You do see the second RPM when you run command "clevo-indicator -?" ?

Some other remarks for Linux and Clevo, although you might know already:

• after updating kernel to 5.3.0-42 big improvements were noted in power consumption & average temperature on my laptop
• TLP installed & enabled, check setting with tlp-stat | egrep 'State|Mode'

[junocomp]

I have a different Clevo model with Nvidia RTX 2060. I doubt the second fan is controlled by Nvidia. I tried other Nvidia fan controllers and they don't seem to work.

This is what I get when I run your script

Simple fan control utility for Clevo laptops
Indicator...
06/10 12:52:25 CPU=36°C, auto fan duty to 10%

I wonder if there is a way for me to detect the second fan.

[deebfeast]

Try first without the GUI. Just run it

clevo-indicator 20
clevo-indicator 30
(etc. try higher just to see).

The output should list both fans speeds as it's read again (might take a second to kick in).
The GUI widget might have to be adjusted on thresholds a bit. It doesn't report on both temperatures or RPM's yet in my code. They are largely the same in any case. You can adjust the strings.

[junocomp]

You are right, I got it to work. Now both fans are detected when running from terminal.

Simple fan control utility for Clevo laptops
Change fan duty to 40%

Dump fan information
FAN Duty: 60%
FA2 Duty: 60%
FAN RPMs: 3593 RPM
FA2 RPMs: 3763 RPM
CPU Temp: 33°C
GPU Temp: 0°C

Do you have an idea how to make it work with the indicator?

Also, thank a million for all of your help

[deebfeast]

Yes, I've not finished that part, although it does work -- just not under all conditions. It's that bit of code in function ec_auto_duty_adjust. There the switching points are defined and I'm sure it could be improved. When I start with setting duty on 20 in the widget and then on auto it seems okay though. But I think it still needs improving a bit with all the thresholds or perhaps initial value somewhere.

[junocomp]

@deebfeast If you figure out how to do it, please let me know and I will buy you a beer/coffee/lunch.

[deebfeast]

Seems okay for me if I start the indicator for the task bar. Note I changed the string to only show one temperature indicator in my source. Also check out that line "if (val < 40 || val > 100)" and change it to allow lower values, like 10 or 20 as well.

clevo-indicator.c.txt

You might still want to fine tune the levels in the following block. First when to go level up, second part is when to level down. This way you can find a reasonable setting for your usage pattern. I'd advice to have the fans really bring it down to under 60 or even 55 during use.

static int ec_auto_duty_adjust(void) {
    int temp = MAX(share_info->cpu_temp, share_info->gpu_temp);
    int duty = share_info->fan_duty;
    //
    if (temp >= 80 && duty < 50)
        return 75;
    if (temp >= 70 && duty < 50)
        return 50;
    if (temp >= 60 && duty < 30)
        return 30;
    if (temp >= 50 && duty < 25)
        return 25;
    if (temp >= 40 && duty < 20)
        return 20;
    if (temp >= 30 && duty < 10)
        return 10;
    //
    if (temp <= 15 && duty > 0)
        return 0;
    if (temp <= 25 && duty > 10)
        return 10;
    if (temp <= 35 && duty > 15)
        return 15;
    if (temp <= 45 && duty > 20)
        return 20;
    if (temp <= 55 && duty > 25)
        return 25;
    if (temp <= 65 && duty > 30)
        return 30;
    if (temp <= 75 && duty > 50)
        return 50;
    //
    return 0;
}

[junocomp]

@deebfeast I just tried your script and the indicator still only controls only one fan. Only when running from the terminal it (clevo-indicator 20) it picks up both fans.

Can you PM by any chance? My email is on my profile.